Area 51 book is out of bounds

Out in a remote expanse of the Nevada desert, a few hours' drive from Las Vegas, lies a vast area of government-owned restricted land where the military and the CIA have conducted a lot of very secret tests since the end of World War II. Now, Annie Jacobsen, a contributing editor at the Los Angeles Times Magazine, has written "Area 51," a deeply flawed, amateurish and at times downright nutty book about it.

First, a little bit of geeky pedantry is called for: "Area 51" is a misleading label. It is a long-disused designation on a specific government agency map. When people hear the term, they commonly associate it with flying saucers or classified aircraft. The latter were indeed tested at a facility at Groom Lake, in the northeastern corner of the map location named "Area 51." Thus, when the government denies that it is doing anything at "Area 51," it's not a lie, because no government has used that map designation for decades.

That area of the desert was used for above and below-ground atomic tests. Groom Lake is a dry lakebed, which made it ideal for aircraft testing back when airplanes often had to make emergency landings on any available flat space. The CIA set up shop there in the mid-1950s because of the lakebed and the area's remoteness from prying eyes. The agency tested the U-2 spy plane there, and later the A-12 OXCART, the predecessor to the much more famous SR-71 Blackbird. Jacobsen recounts a lot of this history, often getting the facts wrong.

Many people, apparently including book reviewers who should know better, will look at her 80-plus pages of notes and assume that this is a "well-researched" book. But simply citing a lot of sources is not a guarantee that the author has used the right ones, or understood them. Many claims in the book are not sourced, and there is ample evidence that Jacobsen missed many key sources.

For example, she never cites Chris Pocock's authoritative 2005 history of the U-2 spy plane with its extensive discussion of Groom Lake, and misses a number of other important sources on classified aircraft development. She claims that former CIA official Albert Wheelon "has given only a few interviews," and seems unaware that he has appeared in a number of television documentaries and spoken to numerous intelligence historians over the years, including me.

A fact-checker could go through "Area 51" and find myriad errors. One common problem is the author's mixing up of dates and organization names. For instance, she claims that representatives of one organization, the National Photographic Interpretation Center, were briefed about the existence of the Groom Lake facility several years before that organization even existed. She claims that the U-2 spy plane was "finally declassified" in 1998, when it had appeared in air shows, one had been hanging in the Smithsonian for nearly two decades, and President Eisenhower had spoken about the aircraft on national television in 1960.

Facts About Area 51 - News


Area 51 book is out of bounds

Now, Annie Jacobsen, a contributing editor at the Los Angeles Times Magazine, has written "Area 51," a deeply flawed, amateurish and at times downright nutty book about it. First, a little bit of geeky pedantry is called for: "Area 51" is a misleading



Roswell UFO, "Area 51" controversies: Nazi link?
Roswell UFO, "Area 51" controversies: Nazi link?

And was the wreckage taken back to the mysterious "Area 51" military base in the Nevada desert? As CNET Executive Editor Molly Wood reported on "The Early Show" Monday, a new book takes a look at Area 51, rekindles debate over both questions - and



Area 51 secrets revealed

SuperFan badge holders consistently post smart, timely comments about Washington area sports and teams. If your comments or those of another user measure up, please let Post editors know. Fact Checkers contribute questions, information and facts to The



Facts & faces

Jacob Stallings hit a two-run single in the third inning and Ben Bunting finished a four-hit day with an RBI double in the ninth for the Tar Heels (51-15), who play Vanderbilt or Florida on Wednesday. Texas (49-19) went two games and out for the second



Nothing strange about Area 51

"The declassified documents I was able to access filled in details and verified facts, but I believe the heart and soul of my book comes from the stories of the legendary Cold Warriors who lived and worked at Area 51," Jacobsen wrote in an email.




AREA 51: COLD RAW FACTS « Clyde Lewis's Ground Zero Media

AREA 51: COLD RAW FACTS

The government has finally declassified the OXCART program at Area 51. Operation Oxcart was a secret operation to develop a supersonic jet that could reach speeds of Mach 3. This was eventually known as the SR-71 blackbird project. Those who play in the world of conspiracy theory already had reported this for many years. The novelty here is that the mainstream media has given the impression that this was the only program that Area 51 was involved in and that anything else “speculative” about reversed alien technology can be put to rest. New ideas are now emerging about what cover stories, and disinformation about UFO’s and aliens to cover up covert testing of special craft that were used for our protection in the paranoid era of the cold war.

What we are getting are table scraps from a project that was well known for years. Not that the scraps are not satisfying, they just create an even bigger appetite for more information, we get the bones and wait for raw meat. Area 51 is a huge onion with layer upon layer that will be revealed when it is necessary. OXCART is finally becoming an official program and the details are being well controlled and all other speculation or books released before the official declassification can all be discounted now right?

Not quite.

My old friend Keith called me to say that I needed to tune into NPR because there was about to be an announcement about Area 51, where a Los Angeles Times Reporter, Annie Jacobsen was about to reveal secrets never revealed about the mysterious air base in Tonopah Nevada. I told him to calm down and that I was going to try and get to her sources so that I can interview them. I had the book in the studio and everything Annie had to say seemed to be wrapped in a government memo that stated that there needed to be a half truth about Russian saucers and Joseph Mengele. While the possibility of the story being true has captured the imaginations of many, I really couldn’t help but say “been there done that—and still no full disclosure.”

Nobody is going to find out about the entire story unless the government wants us to know.

After 16 years reporting the UFO phenomena it has always been difficult to get anyone to talk about anything that goes on at Area 51. It has always been the mantra of the true believers that aliens or even alien space craft are there. The thing is it might not be that way now, and with the cold war a long memory it has now become okay to declassify some of what happened there and there has been all sorts of new so called information that still wraps itself around theories that may or may not be disinformation. However, I side with the idea that half truths and table scraps rather than raw facts are being dropped in our laps about Area 51.


Facts About Area 51 - Bookshelf

Attack of the Killer Facts!, 1,001 Terrifying Truths about the Little Green Men, Government Mind-Control, Flesh-Eating Bacteria, and Goat-Sucking Vampires

Attack of the Killer Facts!, 1,001 Terrifying Truths about the Little Green Men, Government Mind-Control, Flesh-Eating Bacteria, and Goat-Sucking Vampires

Fact attack: Clinton confirms Area 51 (sort of)! In 1995, President Clinton signed an executive order exempting Area 51 from environmental regulation. ...

Deep fire rising

Deep fire rising

While the military continued to deny the existence of the base, these were the most acknowledged facts about Area 51. Mostly, however, the legend of Area 51 ...

Nevada

Nevada

ALL ABOUT NEVADA Fun Facts Nevada's first speed limit was set in Tonopah in 1905 ... Area 51, a military base in southern Nevada, was built in the 1 950s to ...

Area 51, An Uncensored History of America's Top Secret Military Base

Area 51, An Uncensored History of America's Top Secret Military Base

employee at the area, it was my job to know not just who ... up to his own dirty tricks, the true, perilous facts of which have remained buried until now. ...

Area 51: The Mission

Area 51: The Mission

... and the world was still reeling, many not willing to accept these new facts. ... Kelly Reynolds had been drawn into the Area 51 mystery because ...

Day-to-day Articles Directory


HowStuffWorks "How Area 51 Works"
Area 51 is the most famous secret military installation in the world. Learn all about Area 51 and find out why Area 51 is such a heavily guarded secret.

facts about Area 51 - True Knowledge
Show me a profile of Area 51, the US Air Force installation. ... Some Facts About Area 51. Quite a number of people, both professionals and ordinary citizens, believe that ...

What Are Some Facts about Area 51?
Some Facts About Area 51. Quite a number of people, both professionals and ordinary citizens, believe that UFOs have been spotted and found in Area 51. ...

Area 51 - DesertUSA
Area 51 has become a part of popular culture. An installation the U. S. government denies exists is mentioned in everything from video games to serious news programs.

Freaky Facts - Area 51 - Video
A documentary about Aliens and UFO's. Watch Video about Freaky,Facts,Area 51 by Metacafe.com